Ambient light working times of visible light-cured restorative materials. Does the ISO standard reflect clinical reality?

Abstract

Objectives. The aim of this study was to determine whether a custom-built light box could reliably reproduce clinical conditions and whether the current ISO standard test for the working time of visible light cured (VLC) materials (ISO. Dental Resin-based Restorative Materials. ISO:4049, 1991) reflected clinical reality. Method. The ISO test requires a VLC material to remain homogenous after exposure to an 8 kLux light source for 60 s. The relationship between the intensity of ambient lighting and the working times of visible light-cured (VLC) restorative materials was investigated by exposing 23 different VLC composite resin materials to a range of light intensities and measuring the working time in seconds: (a) under clinical operating conditions; (b) in a custom light box at 24 kLux; and (c) at 8 kLux in the light box. Working times were determined by placing 0.06 g samples between two glass plates and gently rotating until clefts or voids appeared. Results: Clinical lighting conditions (24 kLux) gave a mean working time of 54 s (s.d. 14 s). In the light box at 24 kLux the mean working time was 54 s (s.d. 11 s). At 8 kLux (under otherwise identical conditions) the mean working time was 162 s (s.d. 49 s). Significance: A 24 kLux illuminance in the laboratory gives an optimal correspondence to operative lighting conditions. This is three times the lighting level required for ISO purposes, and gives more realistic working times.