Alternate pathways of succession on the Lake Erie Islands

Abstract

In order to determine the effect of prior land use on secondary succession, woody plant species abundances were determined on the Lake Erie Islands in 21 sites 20–90 yr post-abandonment: 11 former vineyards, 8 former orchards, and 2 former quarries. Detrended Correspondence Analysis ordination was used to compare the relative abundances of woody plants in the 21 successional sites to each other and to 5 mature upland forests and 3 mature lowland forests. Vineyards 20–45 yr post-abandonment had closed canopies 2–4 m tall and were dominated by the same mix of species dominating mature forests at similar elevations. Abandoned orchards 20–45 yr post-abandonment supported species common in mature forest floras as well as many shade-intolerant, pioneer tree and shrub species not found in mature stands. These differences in successional patterns seem to be related to differences in the suite of colonization sites presented upon abandonment, with orchards being dominated by open, bare ground, and vineyards by shaded ground receiving ca. 20% of full sunlight. Newly abandoned vineyards had appreciable ‘advanced regeneration’ of saplings of shade-tolerant species 3–7 yr old growing among the grapes. While former quarries remained open, marginal habitats with sparse, open canopies dominated by species typical of rocky cliff edges, the community structure of former vineyards and orchards converged toward each other and toward the composition of mature forests at similar elevations. Thus patterns of secondary succession varied with prior land use and were determined by the suite of colonization sites available at the time of abandonment.