Abstract
Focal hand dystonia in musicians is a movement disorder affecting highly trained movements. Rather than being a pure motor disorder related to movement execution only, movement planning, error prediction, and sensorimotor integration are also impaired. Internal models (IMs), of which two types, forward and inverse models have been described and most likely processed in the cerebellum, are known to be involved in these tasks. Recent results indicate that the cerebellum may be involved in the pathophysiology of focal dystonia (FD). Thus, the aim of our study was to investigate whether an IM deficit plays a role in FD. We focused on the forward model (FM), which predicts sensory consequences of motor commands and allows the discrimination between external sensory input and input deriving from motor action. We investigated 19 patients, aged 19–59 and 19 healthy musicians aged 19–36 as controls. Tactile stimuli were applied to fingers II–V of both hands by the experimenter or the patient. After each stimulus the participant rated the stimulus intensity on a scale between 0 (no sensation) and 1 (maximal intensity). The difference of perceived intensity between self- and externally applied (EA) stimuli was then calculated for each finger. For assessing differences between patients and controls we performed a cluster analysis of the affected hand and the corresponding hand of the controls using the fingers II–V as variables in a 4-dimensional hyperspace (chance level = 0.5). Using a cluster analysis, we found a correct classification of the affected finger in 78.9–94.7%. There was no difference between patients and healthy controls of the absolute value of the perceived stimulus intensity. Our results suggest an altered FM function in focal hand dystonia. It has the potential of suggesting a neural correlate within the cerebellum and of helping integrate findings with regard to altered sensorimotor processing and altered prediction in FD in a single framework.
Highlights
Musicians’ dystonia (MD), a form of focal dystonia (FD), is characterized by a loss of fine motor control of highly trained and automated movements that severely impairs the playing ability and often threatens the professional career.While the phenomenology of MD might imply that it is a pure disorder of movement execution, it has been shown that sensorimotor integration (Wu et al, 2009), movement preparation (Hallett, 2000; Lim et al, 2004), and error prediction (Ruiz et al, 2009) are altered
To assess a potential difference in perception elicited by external stimuli between the healthy musicians and dystonia patients, a Three-Way mixed design analysis of variance (ANOVA) was www.frontiersin.org at the affected fingers but surprisingly manifesting itself at the unaffected fingers alludes at an interaction between all fingers of a higher dimensional order
It is known that MD occurs more often at the dominant side (Baur et al, 2011) and that prognosis is significantly better if the dominant side is affected, which again may be discussed in the context of meta-plasticity, which has been described to be enhanced in musicians (Ragert et al, 2004)
Summary
Musicians’ dystonia (MD), a form of focal dystonia (FD), is characterized by a loss of fine motor control of highly trained and automated movements that severely impairs the playing ability and often threatens the professional career.While the phenomenology of MD might imply that it is a pure disorder of movement execution, it has been shown that sensorimotor integration (Wu et al, 2009), movement preparation (Hallett, 2000; Lim et al, 2004), and error prediction (Ruiz et al, 2009) are altered. A recent study demonstrated that the prediction of temporal characteristics is impaired in writer’s cramp (Avanzino et al, 2013). These findings indicate that mechanisms involved in feed forward motor prediction are compromised. When playing trained musical excerpts on a piano, they found a negative component 70 ms prior to an erroneous action—termed pre-error negativity—which originated in the anterior cingulate cortex (Ruiz et al, 2009), an area that has been described before as being involved in internal model (IM) prediction (Blakemore et al, 1998; Boecker et al, 2005). The same error prediction mechanism was shown to be abnormal in MD (Ruiz et al, 2011) pointing at altered predictive mechanisms
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Sign-in/Register to access full text options 
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a call
