Aggressive Thyroid Cancer is Associated With Suppressor Circulating Immunophenotype

Abstract

Abstract Introduction: The influence of the immune system on follicular cell-derived thyroid cancer behavior has been suggested by various studies but this information has not been comprehensively translated into a prediction for thyroid cancer prognosis. We aimed to identify circulating immune cell profiles associated with thyroid cancer prognosis. This information would be a significant advance in the field of thyroid cancer management. Methods: We performed a single-center prospective cohort study of 32 follicular-cell derived thyroid cancer patients enrolled at the time of initial or subsequent surgery. We performed peripheral blood multi-parameter flow cytometry and collected relevant clinicopathologic, biochemical and radiologic data. We classified patients based on the AJCC TNM cancer stage, American Thyroid Association (ATA) initial risk of recurrence, and status of disease during follow-up. Results: On initial immunophenotyping, patients with aggressive/advanced thyroid cancer (ATA high risk vs. intermediate/low risk; AJCC stage 3/4 vs. 1/2; recurrence or distant metastases vs. no evidence of disease during follow-up) demonstrated increased circulating monocytes and granulocytes but decreased all lymphocytes, T cells (specifically CD4+ and gamma delta) and natural killer (NK) T-like cells. Further immunophenotyping revealed that aggressive/advanced thyroid cancer had increased circulating CD4+CD45+RO effector memory but decreased CD4+CD45+RA central memory T cells and increased regulatory T cells. Stage 3/4 thyroid cancer patients additionally had increased circulating CD33+HLADR- myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSCs) as compared to stage1/2. Conclusions: Aggressive thyroid cancer at presentation (AJCC stage, ATA risk category) or during follow-up (distant metastases) is characterized by a circulating immunophenotype comprising of increased immune suppressor cells (regulatory T cells, MDSCs, effector memory T cells) but decreased immune activator cells (CD4+ T cells, gamma delta T cells, NK T-like cells, central memory T cells) as compared to less aggressive thyroid cancer. This circulating immunophenotype may serve as a biomarker for cancer prognosis and guide the selection and development of novel immunotherapies for advanced thyroid cancer.