Agar dilution test and its Merits and Drawbacks in evolving dynamics of colistin susceptibility

Abstract

ObjectivesAutomated results for determining colistin susceptibility tests are unreliable, micro broth dilution requires expertise, and CBDE has limited dilutions. International Consensus Document of 2022 suggested that agar dilution was unacceptable due to varying results in the literature. MethodsThe study was designed to evaluate the agar dilution method for colistin susceptibility in CRE isolates compared to CBDE. In the study, 108 carbapenem-resistant isolates were tested for Colistin susceptibility by Microbroth Dilution, agar dilution, and colistin broth disc elution. The comparisons were made using various statistical parameters. ResultsThe results of the agar dilution method revealed an essential agreement of 75 % and a categorical agreement of 92.5 %. The method showed a sensitivity of 75 % and a specificity of 97.7 %. The positive and negative predictive values were 88.2 % and 94.5 %, respectively. Youden's index was 0.727, indicating a moderate level of accuracy. Meanwhile, CBDE diagnostic accuracy tests were better, with Youden's index at 0.939. ConclusionsWhile CBDE demonstrated better accuracy parameters, it did not offer a broader MIC range. In contrast, agar dilution showed reasonable specificity and reliability for isolates with high MIC. Therefore, we propose using CBDE for screening and agar dilution as a supplementary test in the approach to colistin susceptibility.