Advancing Personalized Medicine by Analytical Means: Selection of Three Metabolites That Allows Discrimination between Glaucoma, Diabetes, and Controls.

Abstract

This paper aimed at devising an intelligence-based method to select compounds that can distinguish between open-angle glaucoma patients, type 2 diabetes patients, and healthy controls. Taking the concentration of 188 compounds measured in the aqueous humour (AH) of patients and controls, linear discriminant analysis (LDA) was used to identify the right combination of compounds that could lead to accurate diagnosis. All possibilities, using the leave-one-out approach, were considered through ad hoc programming and in silico massive data production and statistical analysis. Our proof of concept led to the selection of four molecules: acetyl-ornithine (Ac-Orn), C3 acyl-carnitine (C3), diacyl C42:6 phosphatidylcholine (PC aa C42:6), and C3-DC (C4-OH) acyl-carnitine (C3-DC (C4-OH)) that, taken in combination, would lead to a 95% discriminative success. 100% success was obtained with a non-linear combination of the concentration of three of these four compounds. By discarding younger controls to adjust by age, results were similar although one control was misclassified as a diabetes patient. Methods based on the consideration of individual clinical chemical parameters have limitations in the ability to make a reliable diagnosis, stratify patients, and assess disease progression. Leveraging human AH metabolomic data, we developed a procedure that selects a minimal number of metabolites (3-5) and designs algorithms that maximize the overall accuracy evaluating both positive predictive (PPV) and negative predictive (NPV) values. Our approach of simultaneously considering the levels of a few metabolites can be extended to any other body fluid and has potential to advance precision medicine. Artificial intelligence is expected to use algorithms that use the concentration of three to five molecules to correctly diagnose diseases, also allowing stratification of patients and evaluation of disease progression. In addition, this significant advance shifts focus from a single-molecule biomarker approach to that of an appropriate combination of metabolites.