Abstract

The Hungarian administrative law has been significantly impacted by the Covid-19 pandemic. Several rules – which were introduced during the state of danger based on the epidemic situation – have been incorporated into the Hungarian legal system. The administrative procedural law has been influenced by the epidemic transformation. However, the rules on e-administration have not been reformed significantly (due to the digitalisation reforms of the last years), but the rules on administrative licenses and permissions have been amended. The priority of the general code on administrative procedure has been weakened: new, simplified procedure and regime have been introduced. The local self-governance has been impacted by the reforms. The transformation has had two, opposite trends. On the one hand, the Hungarian administrative system became more centralised during the last year: municipal revenues and task performance have been partly centralised. The Hungarian municipal system has been concentrated, as well. The role of the second-tier government, the counties (megye), has been strengthened by the establishment of the special economic (investment) zones. On the other hand, the municipalities could be interpreted as a ‘trash can’ of the Hungarian public administration: they received new, mainly unpopular competences on the restrictions related to the pandemic. Although these changes have been related to the current epidemic situation, it seems, that the ‘legislative background’ of the pandemic offered an opportunity to the central government to pass significant reforms. From 2021 a new phenomenon can be observed: the state of danger has remained, but the majority of the restrictions have been terminated by the Government of Hungary. Therefore, the justification of the state of danger during the summer of 2021 became controversial in Hungarian public discourse.

Highlights

  • The first state of danger – which has been declared in Hungary during the first wave of the Covid-19 – ended on ­18 June ­2020, but it has been expected to leave lasting traces in the Hungarian legal system

  • The municipalities could be interpreted as a ‘trash can’ of the Hungarian public administration: they received new, mainly unpopular competences on the restrictions related to the pandemic. These changes have been related to the current epidemic situation, it seems, that the ‘legislative background’ of the pandemic offered an opportunity to the central government to pass significant reforms

  • A new, specific, quasi-emergency situation used to deal with the second wave of the epidemic, as well as the legislation issued in this regard, raises several dogmatic issues that tension the current system of administrative law

Read more

Summary

Introduction

The first state of danger – which has been declared in Hungary during the first wave of the Covid-19 – ended on ­18 June ­2020, but it has been expected to leave lasting traces in the Hungarian legal system. In case of a special legal order (emergency), in accordance with the Fundamental Law, most of the measures defined by Chapters ­21–24 of the DMA could be introduced by the Government, which may issue decrees with a content contrary to the acts of Parliament for a transitional period of 1­ 5 days. The Fundamental Law does not contain regulation on this epidemiological emergency, it is regulated only by the HCA, but it can be interpreted as a new type emergency This solution fits into the trend in the Hungarian legislation, that several quasi-emergencies have been institutionalised by Acts of Parliament, because a similar, quasi-emergency situation is regulated by the DMA during natural and industrial disasters, which are not as serious that the declaration of the state of danger could be justified. It was not specified by the Act whether these sanctions are objective (Nagy, ­2010, pp. ­39–74) ones or they are based on the imputability of the citizens, and the nature of these sanctions is partly obvious

Administrative procedural law and the Covid-19 pandemic
Conclusions
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call