Addressing Transverse Plane Instability in the Modified Lapidus Arthrodesis: A Comparative Study of Screw Versus Suture and Button Fixation Device Technique

Abstract

The Lapidus arthrodesis is a powerful procedure for the correction of hallux valgus with metatarsus primus varus. Yet, first ray instability may persist despite correction of the primary deformity with 2 crossed screw fixation. A third screw is often utilized as the additional point of fixation for noteworthy residual transverse plane motion, but it is not without potential complications. The suture and button fixation device may be an appropriate alternative to the third screw construct. This retrospective cohort study identified clinical / radiographic outcomes and complication rates following a third point of fixation with either a screw or suture and button fixation device in patients undergoing a modified Lapidus arthrodesis. One surgeon performed all of the Lapidus procedure with a third screw while the other surgeon performed all with a suture and button fixation device. Of 136 consecutive patients who underwent a modified Lapidus arthrodesis, 83 (61%) patients required a third point of fixation for satisfactory stabilization of the first ray. Surgical technique was similar between the 2 surgeons; however, one utilized the suture and button fixation device method (n = 36), while the other used a third screw for fixation (n = 47). Many of the clinical outcomes, radiographic results, and the union rate were similar between the 2 methods. Nineteen (40%) complications occurred in the third screw group compared to 6 (17%) in the suture and button fixation device group. However, the third screw group demonstrated 100% maintenance of deformity correction at 1 year versus 95% in the suture and button fixation device group. Although fixation with a suture and button fixation device was associated with fewer complications, a larger study is necessary to determine if these variations are statistically significant.