Addendum

Abstract

Forces between type I collagen triple helices are studied in solvents of varying hydrogen-bonding ability. The swelling of collagen fibers in reconstituted films is controlled by the concentration of soluble polymers that are excluded from the fibers and that compete osmotically with collagen for available solvent. The interaxial spacing between the triple helices as a function of the polymer concentration is measured by x-ray diffraction. Exponential-like changes in the spacing with increasing osmotic stress, qualitatively similar to the forces previously found in aqueous solution, are also seen in formamide and ethylene glycol. These are solvents that, like water, are capable of forming three-dimensional hydrogen-bond networks. In solvents that either cannot form a network or have a greatly impaired ability to form a hydrogen-bonded network, strikingly different behavior is observed. A hard-wall repulsion is seen with collagen solvated by ethanol, 2-propanol, and N,N-dimethylformamide. The spacing between helices hardly changes with increasing polymer concentration until the stress exceeds some threshold where removal of the solvent becomes energetically favorable. No solvation of collagen is observed in dimethoxyethane. In solvents with an intermediate ability to form hydrogen-bonded networks, methanol, 2-methoxyethanol, or N-methylformamide, the change in spacing with polymer concentration is intermediate between exponential-like and hard-wall. These results provide direct evidence that the exponential repulsion observed between collagen helices at 0–8-A surface separations in water is due to the energetic cost associated with perturbing the hydrogen-bonded network of solvent molecules between the collagen surfaces.