Adaptive and neutral genetic differentiation among Scottish and endangered Irish red grouse (Lagopus lagopus scotica)

Abstract

Studying patterns of intra-specific genetic variation among populations allows for a better understanding of population structure and local adaptation. However, those patterns may differ according to the genetic markers applied, as neutral genetic markers reflect demographic processes and random genetic drift, whereas adaptive markers also carry the footprint of selection. In combination, neutral and adaptive genetic markers permit to assess the relative roles of drift and selection in shaping population structure. Among the best understood adaptive genetic loci are the genes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). We here study variation and differentiation at neutral SNP markers and MHC class II genes in red grouse (Lagopus lagopus scotica) from Ireland and Scotland. Irish red grouse populations are fragmented and drastically declining, but red grouse are abundant in Scotland. We find evidence for positive selection acting on the MHC genes and variation in MHC gene copy numbers among Irish individuals. Furthermore, there was significant population differentiation among red grouse from Ireland and Scotland at the neutral SNP markers (FST = 0.084) and the MHC-BLB genes (FST: BLB1 = 0.116, BLB2 = 0.090, BLB3 = 0.104). Differentiation at the MHC-BLB1 was significantly higher than at the neutral SNP markers, suggesting that selection plays an important role in shaping MHC variation, in addition to genetic drift. We speculate that the observed differentiation pattern might be due to local adaptation to different parasite regimes. These findings have strong conservation implications and we advise against the introduction of Scottish red grouse to supplement Irish populations.