Actual encounters of the kidney kind: Exploring 48 cases of renal collision tumors through the lens of literature

Abstract

Multiple tumors of different lineages merging into a single mass, termed collision tumors, are considered a rare phenomenon in the kidney. Tumor components, or partners, may be malignant (including metastatic disease), borderline, or benign. We report the largest cohort to date of 48 cases.The cases were identified from the archives of three institutions in the last 16 years, including 43 (90%) with 2 tumor partners (dyad) and 5 (10%) with 3 partners (triad), totaling 101 individual neoplasms. The majority of cases involved immunohistochemical workup, and 5 underwent FISH or molecular studies.Forty (83%) cases featured a malignant entity, including all triads. Twenty dyads and two triads were composed entirely of malignant tumors. The most common malignant partner was clear cell renal cell carcinoma (RCC) (N = 19) followed by papillary RCC (N = 17). Nine (19%) cases featured borderline entities, including 5 multilocular cystic neoplasms of low malignant potential and 6 clear cell papillary renal cell tumors. Twenty one (44%) cases contained a benign partner, including 6 benign dyads. Papillary adenoma (N = 13) and oncocytoma (N = 8) were most common. Epithelial tumors were present in all 48 cases, and non-epithelial neoplasms in 9 cases (19%).Our cohort includes many novel combinations and collision partners with rare entities such as SDH-deficient RCC, TFE3-rearranged RCC, eosinophilic solid and cystic RCC, and acquired cystic disease associated RCC. A comprehensive literature review and analysis of collision tumor phenomenon in kidney placed these cases in context suggesting that collision tumors of the kidney are more common than previously recognized.