Accuracy, stability, and continuity of AVHRR, SeaWiFS, MODIS, and VIIRS deep blue long-term land aerosol retrieval in Asia

Abstract

The deep blue (DB) aerosol algorithm applied to four satellite instruments, AVHRR, SeaWiFS, MODIS, and VIIRS, produced a long-term aerosol data set since 1989. This study first evaluated and compared the accuracy, stability, and continuity of four DB aerosol optical depth (AOD) products in Asia using AErosol RObotic NETwork measurements. Then, the regional AOD spatial distributions, coverages, and series trends are analyzed. The results show that VIIRS DB has the highest accuracy and stability, with an expected error (EE, ±(0.05 + 20%)) of 76.59% and stability of approximately 0.027 per decade. The performance of MODIS DB is slightly worse than that of VIIRS. However, their AOD pattern, coverage, and trend are comparable. The performance of AVHRR (EE = 58.10%) and the stability of SeaWiFS (0.093 per decade) are less good. Therefore, SeaWiFS DB data should be used with caution for trend analysis. The AOD accuracy and coverage together determine the AOD pattern and the continuity of multi-sensor data. In addition to consistent algorithm accuracy, it is necessary to consider the influences in sensor sampling and inappropriate-pixel screening schemes in the joint multi-sensor analysis. Encouragingly, although multiple DB products have different AOD averages of regional series, their changing trends are consistent. Error analysis shows that the AOD bias characteristic is different in different surface conditions. This indicates that the surface reflectance estimated by the DB algorithm using different techniques is divergent, which may be the direction for the improvement of the algorithm.