Accuracy of Water Displacement Hand Volumetry Using an Ethanol and Water Mixture

Abstract

The traditional water displacement method for measuring limb volume is improved by adding ethanol to water. Four solutions were tested (pure water, 0.5% ethanol, 3% ethanol, and 6% ethanol) to determine the most accurate method when measuring the volume of a known object. The 3% and 6% ethanol solutions significantly reduced (P < 0.001) the mean standard deviation of 10 measurements of a known sphere (390.1 +/- 0.25 mi) from 2.27 ml with pure water to 0.9 ml using the 3% alcohol solution and to 0.6 using 6% ethanol solution (the mean coefficients of variation were reduced from 0.59% for water to 0.22% for 3% ethanol and 0.16% for 6% ethanol). The spheres' volume measured with pure water, 0.5% ethanol solution, 3% ethanol solution, and 6% ethanol solution was 383.2 +/- 2.27 ml, 384.4 +/- 1.9 ml, 389.4 +/- 0.9 ml, and 390.2 +/- 0.6 ml, respectively. Using the 3% and 6% ethanol solutions to measure hand volume blindly in 10 volunteers significantly reduced the mean coefficient of variation for hand volumetry from 0.91% for water to 0.52% for the 3% ethanol solution (P < 0.05) and to 0.46% for the 6% ethanol solution (P < 0.05). The mean standard deviation from all 10 subjects decreased from 4.2 ml for water to 2.3 ml for 3% ethanol solution and 2.1 ml for the 6% solution. These findings document that the accuracy and reproducibility of hand volume measurements are improved by small additions of ethanol, most likely by reducing surface tension of water.