Accuracy of volumetric bone mineral density measurement in high-resolution peripheral quantitative computed tomography

Abstract

Accurate bone mineral density (BMD) quantification is critical in clinical assessment of fracture risk and in the research of age-, disease-, and treatment-related musculoskeletal changes. The development of high-resolution peripheral quantitative computed tomography (HR-pQCT) imaging has made possible in vivo assessment of compartmental volumetric BMD (vBMD) and bone micro-architecture in the distal radius and tibia. HR-pQCT imaging relies on a polychromatic X-ray source and therefore is subject to beam hardening as well as scatter artifacts. In light of these limitations, we hypothesize that the accuracy of HR-pQCT vBMD measurement in the trabecular compartment (vBMD trab) is not independent of bone density and geometry, but rather influenced by variations in trabecular bone volume fraction and cortical thickness. The goal of this study, therefore, was to evaluate the accuracy of HR-pQCT vBMD trab measurement in the radius and tibia, and to determine the dependence of this measurement on geometric and densitometric parameters. Our approach was to use a series of idealized hydroxyapatite (HA) phantoms with varying densities and geometries to quantify the accuracy of HR-pQCT analysis. Two sets of custom-made HA phantoms designed to mimic the distal tibia and distal radius were manufactured. Geometric and densitometric specifications were based on a dataset of healthy volunteers and osteopenic patients. Multiple beam hardening correction (BHC) algorithms were implemented and evaluated in their ability to reduce measurement error. Substantial errors in measured vBMD trab were found. Overestimation of vBMD trab increased proportional to cortical shell thickness and decreased proportional to insert density. The most pronounced vBMD trab overestimation therefore occurred in the phantoms with the lowest insert densities and highest shell thickness, where error was as high as 20 mg HA/cm 3 (33%) in the radius phantom and 25 mg HA/cm 3 (41%) in the tibia phantom. Error in vBMD trab propagates to the calculation of micro-architectural measures; 41% error in vBMD trab will produce 41% error in volume fraction (BV/TV) and trabecular thickness (Tb.Th), and 5% error in trabecular separation (Tb.Sp). BHC algorithms supplied by the manufacturer failed to eliminate these errors. Our results confirm that geometric and densitometric variations influence the accuracy of HR-pQCT vBMD trab measurements, and must be considered when interpreting data across populations or time-points.