Accuracy of formant frequency estimation by spectrograms and by linear prediction analysis

Abstract

The accuracy of spectrographic techniques and of linear prediction analysis in measuring formant frequencies was compared. The first three-formant frequencies of ninety synthetic speech tokens were measured by three experienced spectrographic readers and by linear prediction analysis. The synthetic speech tokens were made by parallel synthesis and were chosen to represent a wide range of formant bandwidths, frequencies, and fundamental frequencies. For fundamental frequencies between 100 and 350 Hz, both methods are accurate to within approximately ±60 Hz for both first and second formants; the third formant can be measured with the same degree of accuracy by linear prediction, but only to within ±120 Hz by spectrographic means. For linear prediction analysis, accuracy does not decrease with increasing fundamental frequency, although the accuracy of both methods decreases greatly when fundamental frequency is 400 Hz or greater. These limits of measurement appear to be within the vicinity of difference limens for formant frequencies. [Supported by NINCDS Grant NS03856.]