Accuracy Assessment of NOAA IMS 4 km Products on the Tibetan Plateau with Landsat-8 OLI Images

Abstract

The NOAA IMS (Interactive Multisensor Snow and Ice Mapping System) is a blended snow and ice product based on active and passive satellite sensors, ground observation, and other auxiliary information, providing the daily cloud-free snow cover extent in the Northern Hemisphere (NH) and having great application potential in snow cover monitoring and research in the Tibetan Plateau (TP). However, accuracy assessment of products is crucial for various aspects of applications. In this study, Landsat-8 OLI images were used to evaluate and validate the accuracy of IMS products in snow cover monitoring on the TP. The results show that (1) average overall accuracy of IMS 4 km products is 76.0% and average mapping accuracy is 88.3%, indicating that IMS 4 km products are appropriate for large-scale snow cover monitoring on the TP. (2) IMS 4 km products tend to overestimate actual snow cover on the TP, with an average commission rate of 45.4% and omission rate of 11.7%, and generally present that the higher the proportion of snow-covered area, the lower the probability of omission rate and the higher the probability of commission rate. (3) Mapping accuracy of IMS 4 km snow cover on the TP generally is higher at the high altitudes, and commission and omission errors increase with the decrease of elevation. (4) Compared with less regional representativeness of ground observations, the spatial characteristics of snow cover based on high-resolution remote sensing data are much more detailed, and more reliable verification results can be obtained. (5) In addition to commission and omission error metrics, the overall accuracy and mapping accuracy based on the reference image instead of classified image can better reveal the general monitoring accuracy of IMS 4 km products on the TP area.