ACC oxidase (ACO) genes in Trifolium occidentale (L.) and their relationship to ACO genes in white clover (T. repens L.) and T. pallescens (L.)

Abstract

The identification and expression of two ACC oxidase (ACO) genes during leaf development in Trifolium occidentale (L.), one of the putative ancestral genomes of the allotetraploid, T. repens (L.; white clover), is described. In common with observations made in T. repens, the ACO genes displayed differential expression, with a TR-ACO2-like gene (designated TO-ACO2) confined to developing and early mature-green leaf tissue while expression of a TR-ACO3-like gene (designated TO-ACO3) is highest in leaves at the onset and during senescence. Biochemical analysis of TO-ACO2 revealed that both accumulation of the protein (determined by western analysis with a TR-ACO2 antibody) and enzyme activity matched the transcriptional activity of TO-ACO2. Western analysis also revealed that the Tr-ACO2 antibody recognised a protein of 37 kDa as a putative TP-ACO2 in T. pallescens. The 3'-UTRs of TO-ACO2 and TO-ACO3 were then compared with the 3'-UTRs of a TR-ACO2-like and TR-ACO3-like gene from T. pallescens, the other proposed ancestral genome (or closely related to the ancestor) of T. repens, with identity values of 87.8% for the ACO2-like genes and 94.8% for the ACO3-like genes. Comparison of the 3'-UTRs of TO-ACO2 with a TO-ACO2-like gene in T. repens (designated TR(O)-ACO2) and TP-ACO2 with a TP-ACO2-like gene in T. repens (designated TR(P)-ACO2) revealed identities of 100% and 96.6%, respectively, lending good support to T. occidentale as one of the ancestral genomes of T. repens. A similar comparison of the 3'-UTRs of TO-ACO3 with a TO-ACO3-like gene in T. repens (designated TR(O)-ACO3) and TP-ACO3 with a TP-ACO3-like gene in T. repens (designated TR(P)-ACO3) revealed identities of 99.5% and 97.9%, respectively, again supporting T. occidentale as one of the ancestral genomes. Further, these data confirm that both TO-ACO-like and TP-ACO-like genes are expressed in the allotetraploid T. repens.