Abstract 4727: Large scale drug response comparison across different neuroblastoma cell model systems

Abstract

Abstract Traditionally neuroblastoma research has predominantly used 2D cell lines, which, despite their simplicity, often fall short in mirroring the physiological complexity of actual tumors. Recently, 3D models like patient-derived tumor organoids (PDO) and patient-derived xenografts (PDX) have emerged as superior alternatives, offering more realistic predictions of patient treatment responses. This study aims to discern the differences in drug response between conventional 2D cell lines and the more advanced 3D neuroblastoma models - specifically, patient-derived organoids (nPDO) and patient-derived xenograft organoids (nPDXO). Employing high-throughput drug screening of 528 cancer drugs, we evaluated the drug responses across traditional 2D cell lines, nPDOs, and nPDXOs. Additionally, focused experiments with 29 selected drugs were conducted to determine the influence of culture topology on drug efficacy. The findings were compared to a study by Hansson et al.1 that used nPDXO. Our study discovered a pronounced difference in drug sensitivity between 2D cell lines and 3D models, with 3D models showing heightened sensitivity. Interestingly, 2D cell cultures had a more heterogenous drug response compared to 3D models. The drug response correlation between nPDOs and nPDXOs was relatively high (Spearman ~0.8), indicating consistent responses across these models. Our comparison underscores the impact of model system choice on drug response studies in neuroblastoma. The study highlights important differences in drug response between neuroblastoma 2D and 3D cell culture models. However, only subtle differences were found between PDO and PDX-derived organoid lines, despite differences in treatment centers and media compositions. This suggests that while the choice of cell culture topology greatly impacts drug response, PDO and PDX derived lines can largely be used interchangeably for drug screening experiments.