Abstract

Introduction:Our recent randomised trial showed that telephone consultations can improve access to asthma reviews without clinical disadvantage.(Pinnock et al, BMJ 2003; 326:477–9) However, concerns have been expressed that telephone consultations in a routine setting may clinically disadvantage patients.Aims and objectives:To compare the effect on asthma morbidity, patient enablement and confidence in asthma managementofroutinely providing atelephone review service vs. a face-to-face review service.Subjects and methods:All registered patients with active asthma (n = 1,213) in a large (n = 31,000) UK practice were included. Existing practice groups were randomised to a review service including a telephone option (TC-option) vs. face-to-face consultations only (FtF-only). Morbidity and enablement questionnaires were sent to all adults and teenagers at 12 months.Results:Questionnaire response rate was 52% (536/1,038). The mini Asthma-related Quality-of-Life and Asthma Control Questionnaires scores were equivalent in both groups: [miniAQLQ: TC-option: 5.29 (SD 1.21) vs. FtF-only: 5.31 (SD 1.24) mean difference 0.02 (95% CI −0.21 to 0.24) p = 0.87] [ACQ: TC-option: 1.20 (SD 1.00) vs. FtF-only: 1.33 (SD 1.13), mean difference 0.12 (95% CI −0.06 to 0.31) p = 0.19]. However, the modified Patient Enablement Instrument and Asthma Bother Profile (management) scores were both significantly improved in the TC-option group: [mPEI: TC-option: 7.29 (SD 4.26) vs. FtF-only: 6.43 (SD 4.30) mean difference −0.83 (95% CI −1.56 to −0.10) p= 0.03] [ABP(m): TC-option: 3.99 (SD 0.84) vs. FtF-only: 3.78 (SD 0.89), mean difference −0.21 (95% CI −0.36 to −0.06) p = 0.007].Conclusions:In a routine setting, providing a telephone option for asthma reviews is equally clinically effective as face-to-face reviews. Average enablement and confidence with asthma management was greater in the TC-option group, perhaps reflecting the increased overall review rate. Conflict of interest and funding None declared. Royal College of General Practitioners Scientific Foundation Board.

Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call