Ability of the exercise electrocardiogram test to detect ischemia in stable coronary artery disease patients with ST-segment depression on the resting electrocardiogram

Abstract

Background The appearance of ST-segment depression on the exercise electrocardiogram (ETT) generally indicates myocardial ischemia. Disorders that produce ST-segment depression on the resting electrocardiogram can confound the results of the ETT. The purpose of this study was to assess the reliability of exercise ST-segment depression as an indicator of ischemia in patients with a resting electrocardiographic ST depression, presumably caused by coronary disease. Methods We studied 882 patients 1 to 6 months after a hospitalization for myocardial infarction or unstable angina as part of the Multicenter Study of Myocardial Ischemia. An ETT and thallium-201 perfusion scan were performed in all patients. For the purpose of this study, the perfusion scan was considered the “gold standard” for ischemia. We correlated the ETT ST-segment responses with the perfusion scan in a group with a normal electrocardiogram baseline ST segment (NO ST DEP group) and in a group with resting electrocardiographic ST depression ≥0.5 mm (ST DEP group). Results Although the frequency of ischemia by perfusion scan was similar in the ST DEP group (48%) to that in the NO ST DEP group (40%), the ST DEP group had a significantly higher (p = 0.03) sensitivity (54%) in detecting ischemia than the NO ST DEP group (35%). The ST DEP group, however, had a lower (58% vs 74%) specificity than the NO ST DEP group (p = 0.056). Baseline characteristics of the two groups probably account for these differences. The overall diagnostic accuracy is similar (58% vs 56%) in the two groups. Conclusion We conclude that in a stable population with known coronary disease, the presence of ST depression on the resting electrocardiogram does not impair the detection of ischemia by the ETT, but may be associated with a higher false-positive rate.(Am Heart J 1998;135:901-6.)