A voluntary activation deficit in m. abductor hallucis exists in asymptomatic feet

Abstract

M. abductor hallucis (AbH) is the strongest intrinsic foot muscle and its dysfunction underlies various foot disorders. Attempts to strengthen the muscle by voluntary exercises are constrained by its complex morphology and oblique mechanical action, which leads to an inability even in asymptomatic individuals to fully activate AbH. This study investigated the extent and magnitude of this inability whilst also providing preliminary evidence for the virtue of targeted sub-maximum neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) as a countermeasure for an AbH activation deficit. The voluntary activation ratio (VAR) was assessed via the twitch interpolation technique in the left AbH of 13 healthy participants during maximum voluntary 1st metatarsophalangeal joint flexion-abduction contractions (MVC). Participants were grouped (”able” or “unable”) based on their ability to fully activate AbH (VAR ≥ 0.9). 7 s-NMES trains (20 Hz) were then delivered to AbH with current intensity increasing from 150% to 300% motor threshold (MT) in 25% increments. Perceived comfort was recorded (10 cm-visual analogue scale; VAS). Only 3 participants were able to activate AbH to its full capacity (able, mean (range) VAR: 0.93 (0.91–0.95), n = 3; unable: 0.69 (0.36–0.83), n = 10). However, the maximum absolute forces produced during the graded sub-maximum direct-muscle NMES protocol were comparable between groups implying that the peripheral contractility of AbH is intact irrespective of the inability of individuals to voluntary activate AbH to its full capacity. These findings demonstrate that direct-muscle NMES overcomes the prevailing inability for high voluntary AbH activation and therefore offers the potential to strengthen the healthy foot and restore function in the pathological foot.