A three-dimensional finite element analysis on the effects of implant materials and designs on periprosthetic tibial bone resorption

Abstract

IntroductionImplant material is a more important factor for periprosthetic tibial bone resorption than implant design after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The virtual perturbation study was planned to perform using single case of proximal tibia model. We determined whether the implant materials’ stiffness affects the degree of periprosthetic tibial bone resorption, and whether the effect of material change with the same implant design differed according to the proximal tibial plateau areas.Materials and methodsThis three-dimensional finite element analysis included two cobalt-chromium (CoCr) and two titanium (Ti) tibial implants with different designs. They were implanted into the proximal tibial model reconstructed using extracted images from computed tomography. The degree of bone resorption or formation was measured using the strain energy density after applying axial load. The same analysis was performed after exchanging the materials while maintaining the design of each implant.ResultsThe degree of periprosthetic tibial bone resorption was not determined by the type of implant materials alone. When the implant materials were changed from Ti to CoCr, the bone resorption in the medial compartment increased and vice versa. The effect of material composition’s change on anterior and posterior areas varied accordingly.ConclusionsAlthough the degree of bone resorption was associated with implant materials, it differed depending on the design of each implant. The effect on the degree of bone resorption according to the materials after TKA should be evaluated while concomitantly considering design.