A theory of shape constancy based on perspective invariants

Abstract

Shape constancy refers to the phenomenon in which the percept of the shape of a given object remains constant despite changes in the shape of the object's retinal image. The phenomenon of shape constancy is considered from historical, theoretical and empirical perspectives in this paper. First, four prior theories are discussed; specifically, (1) Helmholtzian theory, which assumes that shape constancy is achieved by taking an object's orientation into account, (2) Gestalt theory, which assumes that shape constancy involves a relationship between the perceived shape and perceived orientation of an object, (3) Gibsonian theory, which assumes that shape constancy is based on projective invariants and (4) multiple view theory, which assumes that shape constancy is achieved by memorizing a large set of different views of the object. It is shown, by an analysis of the prior literature, that none of these theories can actually explain the phenomenon of shape constancy. A new theory, which is based on new perspective invariants of a flat shape, is then proposed. The new Perspective Invariants Theory can account for all prior shape constancy experiments. New experiments, testing predictions of the Perspective Invariants Theory are then described. These experiments showed that: (1) a novel shape can be matched with its single perspective image in the absence of depth cues, (2) perceptual processing of shape is impaired when the range of possible values of tilt is wide, (3) perceptual processing of shape is not affected by the width of the range of possible values of slant. These results support predictions of Perspective Invariants Theory.