A test of host specialization by insect vectors as a mechanism for reproductive isolation among entomophilous fungal species

Abstract

Epichloë species are self incompatible (heterothallic) fungi that must be fertilized by spermatia from individuals of opposite mating type for successful sexual reproduction to occur. Female flies of the genus Botanophila act as vectors of the fungi by ingesting and defecating spermatia (gametes) onto fungal stromata (fruiting bodies) after oviposition. Larvae feed and develop on the stromata and thus maintain a symbiotic relationship with Epichloë fungi. We hypothesized that sole dependence on fertilized stromata as a food source would promote specialization by flies to single compatible host species and that this specialization would promote reproductive isolation among Epichloë species. Analysis of progeny of ascospores from experimental field plots in Zurich, Switzerland, indicated prevalence of specific matings between stromata of the same host, and thus was consistent with the hypothesis that flies are species‐specific in their visitation behaviour. Genetic analyses of spermatia contained in the faeces of individual flies also gave some support for this hypothesis. We recovered spermatia of 4 different Epichloë species from fly faeces. Comparison of spermatia found in fly faeces to those available from stromata showed flies avoided Epichloë clarkii and may have preferred Epichloë typhina. Interestingly, these are the only two Epichloë species known to be interfertile with one another. Individual flies tended to carry spermatia predominantly from one fungal species. Thus, flies may adopt a type of “majoring” and “minoring” behaviour when visiting fungi. Yet, Botanophila flies are not monolectic and often visited all hosts that were available within screened cages. In addition to any reproductive isolation flies may provide to some fungal species, differences in competitiveness among spermatia of different species deposited on the same stroma may favor intraspecific matings.