A Techno-Economic Framework for Satellite Networks Applied to Low Earth Orbit Constellations: Assessing Starlink, OneWeb and Kuiper

Ogutu B Osoro,Edward J Oughton

doi:10.1109/access.2021.3119634

Abstract

The emergence of Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellite systems has been seen as a potential solution for connecting remote areas where engineering terrestrial infrastructure is prohibitively expensive. Despite the hype, we still lack an open-source modeling framework for assessing the techno-economics of satellite broadband connectivity which is therefore the purpose of this paper. Firstly, a generalizable techno-economic model is presented to assess the engineering-economics of satellite constellations. Secondly, the approach is applied to assess the three main competing LEO constellations which include Starlink, OneWeb and Kuiper. This involves simulating the impact on coverage, capacity and cost, as both the number of satellites and quantity of subscribers increases. Finally, a global assessment is undertaken visualizing the potential capacity and cost per user via different subscriber scenarios. The results demonstrate how limited the capacity will be once resources are spread across users in each satellite coverage area. For example, for 0.1 users per km2 (so 1 user per 10 km2), we estimate a mean per user capacity of 24.94 Mbps, 1.01 Mbps and 10.30 Mbps for Starlink, OneWeb and Kuiper, respectively, in the busiest hour of the day. But if the subscriber density increases to 1 user per km2, then the mean per user capacity drops significantly to 2.49 Mbps, 0.10 Mbps and 1.02 Mbps. LEO broadband will be an essential part of the connectivity toolkit, but the results reveal that these mega-constellations will most likely have to operate below 0.1 users per km2 to provide a service that out-competes other broadband connectivity options.

Highlights

Internet connectivity is a catalyst for societal and economic development, with importance in both emerging and frontier economies [1]–[5]
One of the cheapest ways to supply wide-area broadband connectivity is via cellular technologies, delivery in low and middle-income countries has been dominated by Mobile Network Operators (MNOs) [12], [13]
In this paper a generalizable techno-economic assessment model was developed for satellite broadband constellations

Summary

Introduction

Internet connectivity is a catalyst for societal and economic development, with importance in both emerging and frontier economies [1]–[5]. Over 3 billion of the world’s population are yet to get online, while over 1 billion people are living in an area with no Internet connectivity [7]. New engineering approaches are required to help lower deployment costs and help connect the remaining population [10], [11]. One of the cheapest ways to supply wide-area broadband connectivity is via cellular technologies, delivery in low and middle-income countries has been dominated by Mobile Network Operators (MNOs) (despite governments investing in their own High Throughput Satellite broadband capabilities) [12], [13]. Declining Average Revenue Per User (ARPU) globally has led to static or decreasing revenues, making it even harder to deploy new infrastructure in hard-to-reach areas

Objectives

Results

Conclusion