A systematic review of the management of postoperative scars with silicone gel-based products in randomized controlled trials.

Abstract

Although postoperative scarring may be considered a cosmetic concern, it can greatly impact a patient's quality of life. This extends beyond psychosocial burden influenced by hypertrophic scars and keloids, as patients also experience discomfort and pain. This systematic review evaluates the efficacy of silicone gel (SG)-based products in preventing postoperative abnormal scar formation. Following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, a PubMed search was performed to find randomized, controlled trials investigating the effect of SG-based products on postoperative wound healing. The search yielded 359 publications, but only 30 studies published between 1991-2022 were found to fit the inclusion criteria. Outcomes were extracted from the literature and subsequent quality and risk of bias assessments were performed. Most studies indicated improvement of at least one quality of the scar with the use of SG-based products. The greatest potential variable increasing bias was an inadequate control group. Studies also suffered from small sample sizes, use of unvalidated scar assessment scales, lack of double-blinding, and short follow-up periods. Overall, SG-based products demonstrated potential in preventing abnormal scar formation during postoperative healing, but further studies are required to validate the results of current literature.