A Systematic Review of Renal Functional Reserve in Adult Living Kidney Donors

Abstract

IntroductionThe kidney’s capacity to increase its glomerular filtration rate (GFR) in response to a higher functional demand is known as the renal functional reserve (RFR). Good short-term outcomes after living kidney donation have led to more acceptance of borderline donors (with hypertension, obesity, older age) due the ongoing shortage of donor organs. Given recent concerns about increased long-term risk in some donor subgroups, better donor stratification is needed. Measurement of RFR could inform assessment of donor risk.MethodsA systematic literature review of studies that assessed RFR in donors pre- and/or post-donation was performed. Given study heterogeneity, descriptive analysis and narrative synthesis was conducted.ResultsSixteen of 3250 identified studies published between 1956 and 2019 met inclusion criteria. Most studies were cross-sectional and conducted before (n = 8) and/or after (n = 16) kidney donation. Methods for measurement of GFR, effective renal plasma flow (ERPF) and RFR were not standardized. Changes in filtration fraction (FF) and ERPF relative to GFR observed after donation varied depending on stimulus used to induce RFR. Overall, RFR fell after donation; however, over the shorter term, RFR was largely preserved in young healthy donors. RFR was more significantly reduced in donors with hypertension, obesity, or older age.ConclusionExisting data suggest possible blunting of RFR post-donation in older, obese, and hypertensive donors, which may represent increased single-nephron GFR at baseline. The long-term implications of these changes deserve further study to determine utility in informing selection of borderline kidney donors.