Abstract
Background: Surrogate decision-makers (SDMs) take part in 1.5 million end-of-life (EOL) decisions per year. Most surrogates find the role burdensome, often do make decisions concordant with patients’ wishes and suffer negative psychological after-effects months to years subsequently. Objective: To review the literature and synthesize theoretical models of surrogate decision-making at adult EOL to identify an explanatory foundation for decision support interventions. Design: Literature published up to December 2011 was reviewed using PubMed, MEDLINE, CINAHL and EMBASE using the search terms “surrogate,” “proxy,” “end-of-life,” “life support withdrawal/withholding” and “decision-making”. Study selection: Selection criteria included: (a) studies or integrative reports of the empirical and theoretical research relevant to EOL surrogate decision-making; (b) description of a model of how SDMs make decisions for decisionally-incapacitated adults at EOL and (c) diagrammatic depictions of SDM models specifying key concepts and theoretical relationships. Results: Eight theoretical models met the selection criteria. Data synthesis: Five key insights were that: 1) more consistency is needed between diagrammatic maps of surrogate decision-making and model descriptions; 2) models focused on description of concepts with a lesser focus on relational linkages and propositions; 3) there is a need for greater integration of ethical concepts and their relationships in conceptual maps; 4) there has been little emphasis on how theoretical frameworks might guide intervention development and 5) minimal attempts have been made to situate surrogate decision-making within a grander conceptual framework of decision-making. Conclusions: Several theories of surrogate decision-making at adult EOL have been proposed, but further theory development is needed for these models to serve as the foundation for designing decision support interventions.
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have