A survey on the practice of bronchoscopy in county-level hospitals of China

Abstract

Objective: To investigate the bronchoscopy resource allocation and technology application in county-level hospitals in China. Methods: A cross-sectional survey was conducted. In 2021, 12 provinces were sampled from all provinces in China according to the regional Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and the number of counties, in which a total of 291 county-level hospitals were randomly enrolled. Two county-level hospitals which carried out bronchoscopy technology in each province were randomly sampled to investigate the status of bronchoscopy resources, technical application, decontamination and anesthesia by using questionnaires. Independent sample t test or two related sample nonparametric test were used for comparison between groups. Spearman correlation analysis was used to explore the correlation. Bilateral P<0.05 was considered statistically significant. Results: According to the sampling results, it was estimated that in the county-level hospitals, the proportion of those performing bronchoscopy was 11.4% (9.9%, 13.8%), which was significantly correlated with the population in the province (r=0.64, P=0.025) and the regional GDP (r=0.65, P=0.025).The 24 county-level hospitals interviewed were equipped with (1.6±1.0) bronchoscopes on average, and the number of hospitals with electronic bronchoscopes and fiberoptic bronchoscopes was 22 (91.7%) and 6 (25.0%), respectively. Six (25.0%) hospitals performed bronchoscopy every working day. Twelve (50.0%) hospitals had relatively permanent physicians and nurses. All operating doctors had received special training. There was a significant increase in the number of bronchoscopy cases per hospital in 2020 compared to 2019 [140(70, 335) vs. 100(29, 254), P=0.001]. All hospitals used standard cleaning and sterilization workbenches, cleaning agents and disinfectants. Surface anesthesia was available in 24 hospitals, and bronchoscopy techniques under sedation and analgesia were performed in 10 (41.7%) hospitals. Atropine was still used to prevent airway secretions in 2 (8.3%) hospitals,although not recommended by guidelines. Conclusions: There was a large gap between the current status of bronchoscopy technology in county-level hospitals and the standards of the National Health Commission, together with regional disparities. Bronchoscopist training in the standardization and the decontamination work met the requirements. In some hospitals, the use of complementary medicines was not standardized or the sedatives were not given routinely according to the guidelines. We should promote the popularization and standardization of bronchoscopy technology, and strengthen the allocation of related resources in China's county hospitals.