A Study on the Kinetic Behavior of Listeria monocytogenes in Ice Cream Stored Under Static and Dynamic Chilling and Freezing Conditions

Abstract

The kinetic behavior of Listeria monocytogenes in 2 commercial ice cream products (A and B) that were inoculated and stored under static chilling (4 to 16°C), static freezing (−5 to −33°C), dynamic chilling, and dynamic chilling-freezing conditions was studied, simulating conditions of the aging process and of normal or abuse conditions during distribution and storage. The ice cream products A and B had different compositions but similar pH (6.50 and 6.67, respectively) and water activity (0.957 and 0.965, respectively) values. For both chilling and freezing conditions, the kinetic behavior of the pathogen was similar in the 2 products, indicating that the pH and water activity, together with temperature, were the main factors controlling growth. Under chilling conditions, L. monocytogenes grew well at all temperatures tested. Under freezing conditions, no significant changes in the population of the pathogen were observed throughout a 90-d storage period for either of the inoculum levels tested (103 and 106 cfu/g). Growth data from chilled storage conditions were fitted to a mathematical model, and the calculated maximum specific growth rate was modeled as a function of temperature by using a square root model. The model was further validated under dynamic chilling and dynamic chilling-freezing conditions by using 4 different storage temperature scenarios. Under dynamic chilling conditions, the model accurately predicted the growth of the pathogen in both products, with 99.5% of the predictions lying within the ±20% relative error zone. The results from the chilling-freezing storage experiments showed that the pathogen was able to initiate growth within a very short time after a temperature upshift from freezing to chilling temperatures. This indicates that the freezing conditions did not cause a severe stress in L. monocytogenes cells capable of leading to a significant “additional” lag phase during the subsequent growth of the pathogen at chilling conditions. As a result, the application of the model at chilling-freezing conditions resulted in satisfactory performance, with 98.3% of the predictions lying within the±20% relative error zone. The present study provides useful data for understanding the behavior of L. monocytogenes in ice cream stored under single or combined chilling and freezing conditions. In addition, the study showed that such data can be expressed in quantitative terms via the application of mathematical models, which can be used by the dairy industry as effective tools for predicting the behavior of the pathogen during the manufacture, distribution, and storage of ice cream products.