A study of spatial variability of domoic acid in razor clams: recommendations for resource management on the Washington coast

Abstract

Domoic acid (DA) levels in Washington State razor clams ( Siliqua patula) have been extremely variable and unpredictable, resulting in emergency closures of harvest areas in 1991, 1998, and 1999. Information concerning toxin variability relative to sampling location is important in developing a more reliable plan for managing DA outbreaks. In November 1998, record levels of DA in razor clams (up to 295 ppm) were reported at Kalaloch beach, Washington. A razor clam resource survey conducted there during the summer of 1999, along with the long retention time of DA in the clams, permitted a study of DA levels as a function of tidal elevation and north-south beach location. During the summer low tides (28–31 July 1999) razor clams were collected from six east-west transects, approximately 1.6 km apart. Each clam was individually analyzed for DA to determine the distribution of toxin between (interspecific variability) and within (intraspecific variability) transects. While average DA levels were similar between transects, toxin levels varied substantially among individual clams. The coefficient of variation among all samples ( n=445) was 122%, indicating that harvest closures based upon composite analyses of only six clams could be in error. Here we recommend a sampling strategy of razor clams for regulatory purposes that will result in DA measurements more representative of total population toxin values.