A single-blind, parallel trial of L-hydroxyproline in healthy adult subjects.

Abstract

As calcium oxalate is the most common constituent of urinary stones animal model of the urolithiasis has been established by feeding l-hydroxyproline, an endogenous precursor of oxalate. However, the influence of oral l-hydroxyproline on human urinary oxalate excretion has not been clearly demonstrated. We herein report a clinical study examining the influence of daily ingestion of l-hydroxyproline on urinary oxalate levels with a focus on measuring oxalic acid excreted in the urine. In detail, we performed a single-blind, parallel designed study at Sta. Rosa Hospital and Medical Center, Philippines. This study was approved by the hospital review board and was in compliance with the Declaration of Helsinki. Forty healthy subjects (20 males and 20 females, 33.4 ± 9.4 years of age, who has no history of kidney disease) were divided into 4 groups with 10 subjects in each group with same sex ratio. l-Hydroxyproline doses of 0, 500, 1000 and 2000 mg were taken daily after breakfast for 12 weeks. Prior to and during each scheduled examination, subjects were reminded to refrain from intake of oxalate-rich foods and to drink more than 1 L of water per day. Medical interviews, physical examinations, vital sign measurements, anthropometric measurements, blood examinations and 24-h urine sample collections were conducted every 4 weeks at the hospital. A male and two female subjects were withdrawn from this study because of pregnancy or urinary tract infection so the final number of subjects was 37. Informed consent was obtained from qualified individuals. The baseline characteristics of subjects of each group were not different statistically. No adverse events were observed throughout the trial period except for a few symptoms like itchiness or headache which were self-reported from subjects, but the relationships with the test material were denied by the principle investigator. On the 24-h urine test, almost no markers changed, but there was a significant change in total l-hydroxyproline excretions in the 2000 mg l-hydroxyproline group compared to control group at the point of 8 weeks after first intake. Moreover, oxalic acid levels also increased significantly in the 2000 mg group at the point of 8 and 12 weeks after first intake. However, all values returned to basal values after 4 weeks from the last l-hydroxyproline intake (Table 1). Various dietary factors can change urine oxalate excretion; one is a high-protein diet. Many studies have addressed urinary oxalate excretion after high-protein intake, but conclusions are still uncertain. For example, Knight et al. [1] not only showed significant changes in urinary oxalate with 5 and 10 g of gelatine administered to healthy subjects, but also indicated that the high-protein diet did not influence total daily urinary oxalate excretion [2]. Collagen contains approximately 10 % of l-hydroxyproline, and the daily turnover of collagen in humans is estimated to be 2–3 g/day so the metabolism of l-hydroxyproline will be 240–420 mg [1]. In this study, the urinary oxalate level following 500 or 1000 mg/day l-hydroxyproline ingestion did not change compared with control but 2000 mg/day l-hydroxyproline ingestion increased the urinary oxalate excretion, but the values did not exceed the level of stone forming individuals with a mean oxalate excretion 40 mg/day [2]. As noted, there are various opinions on the association of dietary and urinary oxalate. Recently, it was reported that the Dietary-Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH)-style diet is more effective in reducing calcium oxalate supersaturation than a low-oxalate diet, although it includes a lot of fruits and vegetables which contain much oxalate [3]. Thus, the influence of the diet in conjunction with oxalate is still unclear in human metabolism. Moreover, we found no accumulation of l-hydroxyproline and oxalate in the withdrawal period same as the animal model. The metabolic significance of l-hydroxyproline is still unclear and further investigation is warranted. Table 1 Urinalysis results of 24-h urine sample