A reinterpretation of millimeter observations of nearby IRAS excess stars

Abstract

We analyze new and previously published 1300, 870, and 800 micrometers, single-element bolometer observations of Vega (alpha Lyr), Formalhaut (alpha PsA), epsilon Eri, tau(sup1) Eri, and Beta Leo. We show that these data are consistent with models in which the dust disks around these stars are larger than the radio telescope beams with which they were observed; thus, these disks may be many hundreds of AU in radius or larger. Our interpretation of submillimeter/millimeter measurements of these stars also indicates that for some Infrared Astronomy Satellite (IRAS) IR excess stars the assumption that there is no astrophysical flux in the OFF beams, when using the standard ON-minus-OFF chopping technique and the chop distance is less than 1000AU, may be incorrect. Therefore, for IRAS IR excess stars within approximately 20 pc, virtually all submillimeter/millimeter chopping observations with chop throws less than may have subtracted away some or most of the flux associated with their circumstellar disks. Finally, we present new 1300 micrometers continuum observations of Vega made with chop throws of 500 and 1000 AU. These data are consistent with an interpretation in which Vega has a disk that is at least 1000AU in radius; this disk could have a region with much less material per beam area near 500 AU than at both 100 AU and 1000 AU, corresponding to a gap at the orbital distance of alpha Lyr B. The observations of Vega are also consistent with the assumption that the circumVega dust structure is unresolved. Thus, these new data very effectively illustrate that the 'standard' model of small, unresolved, dust structures around main-sequence IRAS IR excess stars is not unique. Maps of IRAS IR excess stars, which soon will be available from submillimeter/millimeter array detectors, will determine whether the paradigm shift we propose will occur.