A qualitative analysis of the planning, implementation and management of a PDS scheme: Lessons for local commissioning of dental services

Abstract

To identify the experiences of primary care trust employees, the dental teams and other key individuals of the planning, implementation and management of a Personal Dental Services scheme. A thematic analysis of a series of qualitative interviews with 29 individuals who were involved in the planning, implementation and management of a PDS scheme in South East London. Nine key themes were analysed from the data. For each theme perspectives could be identified for both the employees of the primary care trusts and the dental team. These perspectives differ in key respects. Practitioners value the PDS scheme and consider it a positive experience. They suggest that it has led to an increase in quality of care, and a more professional management approach to the practice. The practice team felt that they have benefited from an enhanced working environment. The main concern expressed was that patient registrations were not being accurately assessed. Those involved in the management of the PDS scheme, while endorsing local commissioning arrangements, were concerned that it was not known whether PDS was meeting local needs. There was little quality benchmarking, which would have allowed robust measure of success. The contract model and outcomes should have been more sensitively designed. There was concern expressed that the small number of practices who participated in the pilot scheme prohibits the possibility of thoroughly analysing the impact of local commissioning. Future local commissioning should identify mechanisms for ensuring the effective planning, management and evaluation of the impact of the schemes. A core element of this will be the specification of appropriate goals for commissioning.