A priori assessment of convolutional neural network and algebraic models for flame surface density of high Karlovitz premixed flames

Abstract

Accurate modeling of the unresolved flame surface area is critical for the closure of reaction source terms in the flame surface density (FSD) method. Some algebraic models have been proposed for the unresolved flame surface area for premixed flames in the flamelet or thin reaction zones (TRZ) regimes where the Karlovitz number (Ka) is less than 100. However, in many lean combustion applications, Ka is large (Ka > 100) due to the strong interactions of small-scale turbulence and flames. In the present work, a direct numerical simulation (DNS) database was used to evaluate the performance of algebraic FSD models in high Ka premixed flames in the context of large eddy simulations. Three DNS cases, i.e., case L, case M and case H, were performed, where case L is located in the TRZ regime with Ka < 100 and case M and case H are located in the broken reaction zones regime with Ka > 100. A convolutional neural network (CNN) model was also developed to predict the generalized FSD, which was trained with samples of case H and a small filter size, and was tested in various cases with different Ka and filter sizes. It was found that the fraction of resolved FSD increases with increasing filtered progress variable c̃ and decreasing subgrid turbulent velocity fluctuation u′Δ. The performance of CNN and algebraic models was assessed using the DNS database. Overall, the results of algebraic models are promising in case L and case M for a small filter size; the CNN model performs generally better than the algebraic models in high Ka flames and the correlation coefficient between the modeled and actual generalized FSD is greater than 0.91 in all cases. The effects of c̃ and u′Δ on the performance of different models for various cases were explored. The algebraic models perform well with large values of c̃ and small values of u′Δ in high Ka cases, which indicates that they can be applied to high Ka flames in certain conditions. The performance of the CNN model is better than the algebraic models for a large filter size in high Ka cases.