A personal reflection on the nature of somatic treatments and the implications for mental health nursing.

Abstract

Somatic treatments in psychiatry, ECT (electro-convulsive therapy) and pharmacotherapy, are based on a particular conception of our nature as human beings, and on a particular conception of clinically constructed reality. Acceptance of the basis for such treatments constitutes a tacit admission of our nature as being essentially materialist and deterministic biological machines, and undermines the connectedness which ensures that we each acknowledge the humanity and humanness of the other. By objectifying the other as different (by reason of disordered biology), these connections are severed and allow the imposition of physical forms of treatment in the name of cure. In this personal reflection, I draw upon my own experience of ECT from a nursing perspective, and attempt to explain the basis of my antipathy for this treatment. In the course of this exploration I also raise some of the issues which I feel nursing must deal with if it is to continue uncritically to adopt the biological paradigm as the basis of its praxis.