A note on the paper “A novel approach of graphical rectangular b-metric spaces with an application to the vibrations of a vertical heavy hanging cable”

Abstract

In this work, a counterexample is given to refute a result in the paper by Younis et al. (J Fixed Point Theory Appl 21:1–33, 2019). Furthermore, applying this counterexample, we give negative answers to some of the open problems in their paper. Recently, Baradol et al. give a new theorem to rectify the result of Younis et al. However, we find that there are some gaps in the proofs of their results. Finally, we introduce a fundamental lemma and fill these gaps.