A New Research on the Russian Federation as a Subject of Civil Law (To Publication of the Monograph by Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor V. G. Golubtsov "The Russian Federation as a Subject of Civil Law" (Moscow: Statut; 2019))

V L Slesarev

doi:10.17803/1729-5920.2020.166.9.165-169

Abstract

The review covers the monograph by Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor V. G. Golubtsov "The Russian Federation as a Subject of Civil Law" (Moscow, 2019). The reviewer appreciates the following. Firstly, the aspect of research, namely a complete and comprehensive analysis of the status of the Russian Federation as a subject of civil law, and the way the author considers these problems from the standpoint of civil law. Secondly, deeply reasoned monographic position give a great opportunity to reflect on the set of the problems and proposed solutions and to maintain or introduce more or different positions. The work is well structured: the approach chosen by the author allows us to express and justify his views on the entire range of issues related to the participation of the Russian Federation in public relations as a subject of civil law. At the same time, the volume of work is so large, and the rationale for author’s decisions is so rich, that the reviewer expresses his position only on one, but the most fundamental issue presented in the monograph, namely, the legal nature of state property rights. According to the author, state property relations are included in the subject of civil law regulation, the method of which is such legal techniques as equality, autonomy of will and property independence. The state, acting directly or indirectly, when rejecting public rights and privileges that do not correspond to this method, should be considered as a special subject of these civil relations, acting along with "classical" subjects — individuals and legal entities. According to the reviewer, on the contrary, property relations of state property do not have a commodity-monetary form and, therefore, cannot be included in the subject of civil law regulation. The review provides arguments in favor of the latter position.

Highlights

The review covers the monograph by Dr. Sci
the way the author considers these problems from the standpoint of civil law
deeply reasoned monographic position give a great opportunity to reflect on the set of the problems

Summary

Introduction

Глава 3 «Российская Федерация как участник вещных правоотношений» состоит из трех параграфов, в которых представлены результаты исследования, во-первых, относительно участия Российской Федерации в правоотношениях собственности; во-вторых, применительно к объектам права собственности Российской Федерации; в-третьих, касающихся разграничения государственной собственности в Российской Федерации. Г. Голубцовым, заключается в том, что отношения государственной собственности включены в предмет гражданско-правового регулирования, методом которого являются такие правовые приемы, как равенство, автономия воли и имущественная самостоятельность. С. Якушев По его мнению, имущественные отношения государственной собственности не имеют товарно-денежной формы и потому не могут включаться в предмет гражданско-правового регулирования.

Results

Conclusion