A New Estimate of Transaction Costs

Abstract

Transaction costs are important for a host of empirical analyses from market efficiency to international market research. But transaction costs estimates are not always available, or where available, are cumbersome to use and expensive to purchase. We present a model that requires only the time series of daily security returns to endogenously estimate the effective transaction costs for any firm, exchange, or time period. The feature of the data that allows for the estimation of transaction costs is the incidence of zero returns. Incorporating zero returns in the return-generating process, the model provides continuous estimates of average round-trip transaction costs from 1963 to 1990 that are 1.2% and 10.3% for large and small decile firms, respectively. These estimates are highly correlated (85%), with the most commonly used transaction cost estimators. How much does it cost to trade common stock? The Plexus Group (1996) estimated that trading costs are at least 1.0-2.0% of market value for institutions trading the largest NYSE/AMEX firms. Such trades account for more than 20% of reported trading volume. Stoll and Whaley (1983) reported quoted spread and commission costs of 2.0% for the largest NYSE size decile to 9.0% for the small decile. Bwardwaj and Brooks (1992) reported median quoted spread and commission costs between 2.0% for NYSE securities with prices greater than $20.00 and 12.5% for securities priced less than $5.00. These costs are important in determining investment performance and can substantially reduce or possibly outweigh the expected value created by an investment strategy [Keim and Madhavan (1995)]. This article is based on a portion of the first chapter of David A. Lesmond's dissertation entitled: Trans