Abstract
Recent clinical trials failed to endorse dichoptic training for amblyopia treatment. Here, we proposed an alternative training strategy that focused on reducing signal threshold contrast in the amblyopic eye under a constant and high noise contrast in the fellow eye (HNC), and compared it to a typical dichoptic strategy that aimed at increasing the tolerable noise contrast in the fellow eye (i.e., TNC strategy). We recruited 16 patients with amblyopia and divided them into two groups. Eight patients in Group 1 received the HNC training, while the other eight patients in Group 2 performed the TNC training first (Phase 1) and then crossed over to the HNC training (Phase 2). We measured contrast sensitivity functions (CSFs) separately in the amblyopic and fellow eyes when the untested eye viewed mean luminance (monocularly unmasked) or noise stimuli (dichoptically masked) before and after training at a particular frequency. The area under the log contrast sensitivity function (AULCSF) of masked and unmasked conditions, and dichoptic gain (the ratio of AULCSF of masked to unmasked condition) were calculated for each eye. We found that both dichoptic training paradigms substantially improved masked CSF, dichoptic gain, and visual acuity in the amblyopic eye. As opposed to the TNC paradigm, the HNC training produced stronger effects on masked CSFs, stereoacuity, dichoptic gain, and visual acuity in the amblyopic eye. Interestingly, the second-phase HNC training in Group 2 also induced further improvement in the masked contrast sensitivity and AULCSF in the amblyopic eye. We concluded that the HNC training strategy was more effective than the TNC training paradigm. Future design for dichoptic training should not only focus on increasing the tolerable noise contrast in the fellow eye but should also “nurture” the amblyopic eye under normal binocular viewing conditions and sustained interocular suppression.
Highlights
Amblyopia, a neurodevelopmental vision disorder caused by abnormal visual experience during early childhood, affects about 2–5% of the population (Kiorpes et al, 1998; Holmes and Clarke, 2006)
By comparing the data from Group 1 and the first training phase of Group 2, we evaluated the efficacies of the two training strategies (HNC vs. training with progressive noise contrast (TNC)) on recovering monocular and binocular performance in amblyopia, e.g., the magnitudes of improvement, measured in terms of percent change of area under the log contrast sensitivity function (AULCSF) at amblyopic eye masked (AEM), amblyopic eye unmasked (AEU), dichoptic gain, visual acuity, and stereoacuity (Figure 6)
We found that the high and constant noise contrast (HNC) training produced significantly greater improvements in the AEM contrast sensitivity (t14 = 2.841, P = 0.025) at the training spatial frequency, AEM AULCSF (t14 = 2.367, P = 0.033) and dichoptic gain (t14 = 2.289, P = 0.038), indicating that the HNC strategy is more effective than the TNC strategy in promoting the amblyopic eye to counteract the masking effect from the fellow eye
Summary
A neurodevelopmental vision disorder caused by abnormal visual experience during early childhood, affects about 2–5% of the population (Kiorpes et al, 1998; Holmes and Clarke, 2006) Amblyopia leads to both monocular deficits in the amblyopic eye, e.g., impaired visual acuity (Levi, 2006), reduced contrast sensitivity (Hess and Howell, 1977; McKee et al, 2003), unsteady monocular fixation (Subramanian et al, 2013), and abnormal binocular vision, e.g., interrupted binocular summation (Huang et al, 2009) and binocular rivalry (Lunghi et al, 2016), asymmetric dichoptic masking (Shooner et al, 2017; Zhou et al, 2018) and interocular suppression (Li J. et al, 2011), and reduced stereoacuity (Levi et al, 2015). The development of binocular treatment for amblyopia is necessary to recover deficient binocular vision in amblyopia
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Sign-in/Register to access full text options 
Free) 
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a call
