A multitasking assessment for aphasia: The Catalog Ordering Task

Abstract

Multitasking assessments based on everyday scenarios are useful assessment tools that can reveal the consequences of language and cognitive impairments on functioning. Unfortunately, many existing multitasking assessments require a high degree of linguistic processing that may preclude their use with adults with aphasia. The purposes of this paper are to (1) describe the development of a multitasking assessment relevant to everyday activities, the Catalog Ordering Task (COT), specifically designed for aphasia, (2) investigate differences between the performances of adults without aphasia and adults with aphasia on the COT, and (3) explore the relationships between language and cognitive performances and the COT to facilitate clinical utility. Seventy-four participants, 40 adults with aphasia and 34 people without aphasia, completed the multitasking assessment in single and dual task conditions. The secondary task in the dual task condition was a tone detection task requiring a foot-pedal press. Participants with aphasia also completed additional language and cognitive assessments. We systematically developed the Catalog Ordering Test (COT) with considerations for semantics, syntax, and ecological validity. Criterion validity with acceptable levels of inter-rater and test-retest reliability were observed. Adults with aphasia performed with about half the accuracy and twice as slowly as people without aphasia. Adults with all severity levels of aphasia were able to complete the COT. Multitasking performance on the COT was related to impairment-level measures of language and cognition. The COT is a potentially clinically useful assessment of multitasking, specially designed for aphasia.