A Hybrid Clustered Ant Colony Optimization Approach for the Hierarchical Multi-Switch Multi-Echelon Vehicle Routing Problem with Service Times

Abstract

In this paper, the Hierarchical Multi Switch Multi Echelon Vehicle Routing Problem with Service Times (HMSME-VRP-ST) is presented. This novel problem considers distribution applications in which goods are delivered either directly from a central depot or through intermediate facilities called switch points. Commodities are loaded into interchangeable containers called swap bodies at the central depot, and can be transferred from one vehicle to another at the switch points. The goal is to minimize fixed and variable costs of the vehicle fleet and swap-bodies while serving a predetermined set of customers. The routes are constrained by time and swap bodies by loading capacity. A mathematical model of the HMSME-VRP-ST is presented, and a Hybrid Clustered Ant Colony Optimization (HCACO) algorithm is proposed to address the complexity of the problem. The approach utilizes the ant-based clustering algorithm, combining the density and connectivity properties of clustering for creating promising neighborhoods with the solution construction methodology and pheromone-based memory of the Ant Colony Optimization framework. Additionally, two local search schemes based on Variable Neighborhood Descent are incorporated to further improve the generated solutions. The behavior of each HCACO variant is analyzed, and their results are compared to a Greedy Randomized Adaptive Search Procedure metaheuristic in 36 newly generated benchmarks comprising of clustered, uniformly random, and mixed clustered-random instances.