A Graph Theory Approach for Placing Overcurrent Relays and Reclosers for Economical Protection of Meshed Transmission Networks

Abstract

Penetration of the power grid by renewable energy sources, distributed storage, and distributed generators is becoming more widespread. Increased utilization of these distributed energy resources (DERs) has given rise to additional protection concerns. With radial feeders terminating in DERs or in microgrids containing DERs, standard non-directional radial protection may be rendered useless. Moreover, coordination will first require the protection engineer to determine what combination of directional and nondirectional elements is required to properly protect the system at a reasonable cost. In this paper, a method is proposed to determine the type of protection that should be placed on each line. Further, an extreme cost constraint is assumed so that an attempt is made to protect a meshed network using only overcurrent protection devices. A method is proposed where instantaneous reclosers are placed in locations that cause the system to temporarily become radial when a fault occurs. Directional and nondirectional overcurrent (OC) relays are placed in locations that allow for standard radial coordination techniques to be utilized while the reclosers are open to clear any sustained faults. The proposed algorithm is found to effectively determine the placement of protection devices while utilizing a minimal number of directional devices. Additionally, it was shown for the IEEE 14-bus case that the proposed relay placement algorithm results in a system where relay coordination remains feasible.