Abstract

Katz and King have previously developed a model for predicting or explaining aggregate electoral results in multiparty democracies. Their model is, in principle, analogous to what least-squares regression provides American political researchers in that two-party system. Katz and King applied their model to three-party elections in England and revealed a variety of new features of incumbency advantage and sources of party support. Although the mathematics of their statistical model covers any number of political parties, it is computationally demanding, and hence slow and numerically imprecise, with more than three parties. In this paper we produce an approximate method that works in practice with many parties without making too many theoretical compromises. Our approach is to treat the problem as one of missing data. This allows us to use a modification of the fast EMis algorithm of King, Honaker, Joseph, and Scheve and to provide easy-to-use software, while retaining the attractive features of the Katz and King model, such as thetdistribution and explicit models for uncontested seats.

Highlights

  • We offer a computationally feasible algorithm, and easy-to-use software, that approximates Katz and King’s (KK) (1999) full information maximum likelihood (FIML) model of district-level multiparty electoral data

  • In addition to treating vote share as a compositional variable, our approach allows us to model vote share as t distributed and enables us to use election data where not all parties contest in every district

  • We present the results in several stages, beginning with the mean square error (MSE) for each model under the two data generation processes

Read more

Summary

Introduction

We offer a computationally feasible algorithm, and easy-to-use software, that approximates Katz and King’s (KK) (1999) full information maximum likelihood (FIML) model of district-level multiparty electoral data. Scholars can use our method and software with aggregate multiparty electoral data (and related explanatory variables coded or aggregated at the district level) to explain, predict, or infer about counterfactuals in real election results. In addition to treating vote share as a compositional variable, our approach allows us to model vote share as t distributed and enables us to use election data where not all parties contest in every district. These can be important features of political science data. We present Monte Carlo comparisons of KK with our method in three-party data and replicate KK’s empirical results with our methods (Section 4). We replicate a real empirical article and show how the substantive results change when our improved method is applied (Section 6)

Notation and the Full Information Approach
Overview of Our Alternative Approach
Monte Carlo Comparison of KK and Our Method
Replicating KK’s Empirical Results
Concluding Remark
Some Useful Properties of the t Distribution
An EMis Algorithm for t-Distributed Data
Imposing Uncontestedness Constraints
Findings
The t Regression Analysis Model
Full Text
Paper version not known

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call