A crossover comparative study to assess efficacy of competency based medical education (CBME) and the traditional structured (TS) method in selected competencies of living anatomy of first year MBBS curriculum: A pilot study

Abstract

BackgroundCompetency based medical education (CBME) is outcome based teaching methodology where a student learns a set of measurable competencies for early clinical exposure. Inspite of ample resources on CBME, there are limited studies on its implementation. This study will try to demonstrate improvement in the performance of students using CBME as a teaching tool over the traditional structured method (TS). MethodsForty student volunteers were chosen and divided into two groups. The crossover design exposed the group of students to CBME and TS spread over two periods with a wash out period in between. The intervention group was exposed to selected list of competencies in living Anatomy with feedbacks and formative assessments. The summative assessments were held at the end of each period. ResultsThe mean scores of CBME and TS in group 1 is 130.625 and 113.65 while in group 2 is 139.425 and 112.075 respectively. The treatment and period effect is significant. Estimate of treatment effect is 22.1625. The average improvement in treatment scores is by 11%. Two tailed paired sample T test reveals significant improvement in the scores post intervention. ConclusionCBME method produces better performance of the students in the competencies of living anatomy.