A comparison of root architecture and shoot morphology between naturally regenerated and container-grown seedlings of Quercus ilex

Abstract

We explored the different mechanisms developed by naturally regenerated seedlings of Quercus ilex L. (Holm oak) under Mediterranean conditions compared to container-seedlings commonly used in plantations. We examined the differences in root architecture (including topology and morphology) and shoot parameters. The results showed that there are many differences in the architecture of the root system as well as in the shoot morphology between the two types of seedlings. The naturally regenerated seedlings were smaller with regard to most of the shoot and root parameters, but they developed a longer taproot, only first order lateral roots, and presented a more herringbone-like root system compared to the container seedlings. Conversely, all types of container seedlings, were larger and had a more extended root system with many orders of lateral roots, while their taproot length was restricted within the container’s depth. The quotient log (α)/ log (μ) for all seedlings, showed a tendency to decrease with plant size. A strict herringbone root system with an elongated taproot may be the optimal root architecture for Quercus ilex L. seedlings in order to survive under Mediterranean conditions.