A comparison of halothane homozygous negative and positive pietrain sire lines in relation to carcass and meat quality, and welfare traits

Abstract

Barrows ( n=164) and gilts ( n=249) from crosses of a Pietrain homozygous halothane recessive (Pi nn) and two Pietrain homozygous dominant (Pi NN-a and Pi NN-b) sire lines with Landrace×Large White NN sows, were used to study the effect of terminal sire and pre-slaughter treatment on meat quality and animal welfare. The pigs from each of the two farms where they were finished were delivered to the abattoir in two batches differing in the pre-slaughter conditions. A total of 90 pigs (54 NN and 36 Nn) were assigned to a long pre-slaughter treatment (6 h transport and 14.5 h lairage) and 89 (57 NN and 33 Nn) to a short pre-slaughter treatment (4.5 h transport and 2.5 h lairage) in Farm 1, and 118 (65 NN and 53 Nn) to the long (7 h transport and 14 h lairage) and 114 (66 NN and 48 Nn) to the short pre-slaughter treatment (1.5 h transport and 2 h lairage) in Farm 2. In Farm 1, heart rate of 3 NN and 3 Nn gilts was recorded throughout loading and transport and blood samples from 5 NN and 5 Nn were collected before loading and after transport to measure cortisol, creatine phosphokinase (CPK) and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH). Carcasses were classified and commercial cutting was carried out. At 24 h, meat quality was assessed on the Longissimus thoracis muscle by measuring electrical conductivity (PQM), colour (Minolta CR 200 and Japanese scale), pHu and drip losses. Halothane carriers showed a higher mean heart rate and higher increase in CPK levels ( P<0.05) after transport in the short pre-slaughter treatment than halothane free pigs. No effect was observed in cortisol or LDH values. Pi NN-a sired pigs had a higher live and carcass weight ( P<0.001) and loin depth ( P<0.05), but lower killing out percentage ( P<0.01) and leg yield ( P<0.01) compared with the progeny of the other two terminal sires. Gilts were leaner ( P<0.001), had a higher killing out percentage ( P<0.001) and higher yields of primal cuts ( P<0.001) compared with barrows. Pi nn sired pigs had poorer meat quality (higher PQM values in both farms, P<0.01) than Pi NN-a sired pigs. Long pre-slaughter treatment resulted in darker meat ( P<0.01) in both farms and in higher pHu ( P<0.001) in Farm 1 than short pre-slaughter treatment. Conversely, pigs subjected to the short pre-slaughter treatment showed higher PQM values ( P<0.01) in Farm 1 and higher PSE percentage ( P<0.05) in both farms compared to the ones subjected to the long pre-slaughter treatment. These results suggest that Pietrain halothane free sire lines could produce similar results on carcass quality to halothane carriers, without compromising meat quality and welfare.