A Comparative Study on the Variation in Seropositivity Rates After 2-Dose COVID-19 Vaccination Before or After Transplant: A Single-Center Analysis

Abstract

Many researchers have demonstrated that the seropositivity rate after SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus vaccination is lower in patients receiving oral immunosuppressants. In this article, we report on a comparative study on the seropositivity rate after 2 doses of coronavirus vaccine before or after kidney transplant. We studied 111 recipients vaccinated after transplant, 19 patients vaccinated before transplant, and 10 healthy patients. We retrospectively measured antibody titers using preserved serum samples. The antibody testing was performed 1 month and 3 months after vaccination. The measurement was via LABScreen COVID Plus, which enables simultaneous determination of 5 coronavirus protein antigens. Seropositivity to coronavirus antibodies was observed in all 19 patients vaccinated before transplant (100%) and in all the 10 healthy patients (100%). Forty- six of the 111 recipients (42%) vaccinated after transplant developed seropositivity. Analyzed at each time point after vaccination, the mean fluorescence intensity of antibodies was unchanged between 1 month and 3 months after vaccination in transplant recipients who were vaccinated after transplant and developed seropositivity. On the other hand, the antibody mean fluorescence intensity in patients vaccinated before transplant was markedly lower at 3 months (posttransplant). All patients with renal failure who were vaccinated before transplant showed a high seropositivity rate, similar to that in healthy patients. The seropositivity rate for each of the viral fragment antibodies in patients vaccinated before transplant was maintained, as seen in healthy patients. However, in patients vaccinated before transplant who tested positive for antibody production at 1 month after vaccination,the antibody mean fluorescence intensity at 3 months after vaccination (posttransplant) was remarkedly lower than the mean fluorescence intensity at 1 month, which was probably caused by the types of immunosuppressive regimens used atthe time of transplant.