A comparative study on resistance spot and laser beam spot welding of ultra-high strength steel for automotive applications

Abstract

In this study, the effect of resistance spot welding (RSW) and laser beam spot welding (LBSW) processes on evolution of microstructure, load endurance capabilities, heat affected zone (HAZ) softening, and corrosion resistance of ultra-high-strength (UHSS) steel joints welded in lap joint design is investigated. The UHSS sheets of dual phase 1000 grade (UHSDP1000) having 1.20 mm thickness were joined using the RSW and LBSW parameters optimized by response surface methodology (RSM). The microstructural features of welding regions of RSW and LBSW joints were studied using optical microscopy (OM). The load endurance capabilities of RSW and LBSW joints were assessed using the tensile shear failure load (TSFL) and cross-tensile failure load (CTFL) tests. The ruptured surfaces of TSFL and CTFL tested samples were examined utilizing scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The microhardness distribution of divergent regions of RSW and LBSW joints was evaluated and imputed to the TSFL and CTFL failure of joints. The corrosion resistance of RSW and LBSW joints was analyzed using potentiodynamic corrosion and immersion corrosion tests. The RSW joints showed 183% and 62.79% greater TSFL and CTFL endurance capabilities than LBSW joints. The TSFL and CTFL endurance capabilities of LBSW joints are inferior to RSW joints due to the smaller load bearing area. It causes the stress concentration in FZ and HAZ of LBSW joints. The RSW joints and LBSW joints disclosed TSFL and CTFL failure in button pull out rupture mode with tearing of HAZ. The failure of RSW and LBSW joints in HAZ is due to the softening caused by martensitic tempering and coarsening of grains. The LBSW joints disclosed inferior resistance to corrosion than RSW joints due to the higher martensite content which contributes to greater fraction of favorable pitting sites and decreased corrosion resistance.