Abstract
In this study, a comparative evaluation of the statistical methods for daily streamflow estimation at ungauged basins is presented. The single donor station drainage area ratio (DAR) method, the multiple-donor stations drainage area ratio (MDAR) method, the inverse similarity weighted (ISW) method, and its variations with three different power parameters (1, 2, and 3) are applied to the two main subbasins of the Euphrates Basin in Turkey to estimate daily streamflow data. Each station in each basin is considered in turn as the target station where there are no streamflow data. The donor stations are selected based on the physical similarities between the donor and target stations. Then, streamflow data from the most physically similar donor station(s) is transferred to the target station using the statistical methods. In addition, the effect of data preprocessing on the estimation performance of the statistical methods is investigated. The preprocessing discussed in this study is streamflow data smoothing using the two-sided moving average (MA). Three statistical methods using the smoothed data by the MA, named as DAR-MA, MDAR-MA, and ISW-MA, are proposed. The estimation performance of the statistical methods is compared by using daily streamflow data with preprocessing and without preprocessing. The Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE), the ratio of the root mean square error (RMSE) to the standard deviation of the observed data (RSR), the percent bias (PBIAS), and the coefficient of determination (R2) are used to evaluate the performance of the statistical methods. The results show that MDAR and ISW give improved performances compared to DAR to estimate daily streamflow for 7 out of 8 target stations in the Middle Euphrates Basin and for 4 out of 7 target stations in the Upper Euphrates Basin. Higher NSE values for both MDAR and ISW are mostly obtained with the three most physically similar donor stations in the Middle Euphrates Basin and with the two most physically similar donor stations in the Upper Euphrates Basin. The best statistical method for each target station exhibits slightly greater NSE when the smoothed data by the MA is used for all target stations in the Middle Euphrates Basin and for 6 out of 7 target stations in the Upper Euphrates Basin.
Highlights
In recent years, several factors, such as climate change, global warming, drought, population growth, and industrialization, have led to a rapid increase in demand for water
The results show that multiple-donor stations drainage area ratio (MDAR) and inverse similarity weighted (ISW) give improved performances compared to drainage area ratio (DAR) to estimate daily streamflow for 7 out of 8 target stations in the Middle Euphrates Basin and for 4 out of 7 target stations in the Upper Euphrates Basin
In order to test the effect of different power parameter selection in the use of the ISW method on the accuracy of daily streamflow estimation, the ISW method was applied with power parameters of 1, 2, and 3
Summary
Several factors, such as climate change, global warming, drought, population growth, and industrialization, have led to a rapid increase in demand for water. Measurements and estimates of streamflow play an important role in the stage of the planning and implementation of the water budget. Streamflow estimation at ungauged and poorly gauged basins is an important issue in growing economies countries such as Turkey because there are a limited number of stations in the streamflow gauging network of Turkey and streamflow estimates are often needed at ungauged basins where water resources projects are planned. Some stations in the river basins of Turkey contain large amounts of missing data during the observation period [2,3] This lack of adequate data creates significant problems in the water resources projects for Turkey. For these reasons, accurate measurement and analysis of streamflow data and reliable streamflow estimates are needed
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Sign-in/Register to access full text options 
Free) 
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a call
